Planning for regional waste water systems : its relationship to land use and social structure /
No Thumbnail Available
Date
1973
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Rutgers University, New Jersey,
New Jersey :
New Jersey :
Abstract
An analysis is made of planning for regional waste
water systems in the New Jersey portion of the New York
Metropolitan Region, with speciol attention given to the
Hackensack drainage basin (which also includes a portion
of Rockland County, Now York) and the Bergen County
Sewerage Authority. Also included are case studies
covering the New Jersey portion of the Philadelphia
Metropolitan Region, the proposed Tocks Island and
Deepwater projects, and the North Branch of the Raritan River.
It was found that decision making for waste water
planning for these areas is not truly regional in scope
in that it is based on political boundaries rather than
those of a major drainage basin and/or metropolitan
area. Nor is it comprehensive in that it fails to involve
the coordination of various elements and functions,
such as water supply and land use planning, and does not
serve the public interest. Finally, the process of
planning is found to be incremental rather than rational,
in that it docs not tonal to involvo tho c:Jtnbli:.Jhmont of
gonzo, nltorn~tivo moons to attain tho gonln, end policies
to effect unto goal attuinmont.
A largo-scnlo regional wosto wntor oystom covering tho
groator portion of o mnjor droinngo bnsin (tho Bereon Councy
Seworngo Authority) was compared to a local smnll-scnle
system serving a sub-bnnin (tho North West Borgen Gounty
Sewerage Authority). It was found thnt tho lurge-scale
system which has boon operating for over twenty years, is
no more effective than the amnll-scalo system in improving
stream quality and augmenting stream use. The large-scale
system mny have helped maintain water quality levels in
the low-density affluent communities at the basin's headwaters,
but there has been no appreciable improvement in
water quality for most of the people served by the system
in the downstream areas. While tho large-scale system may
offer lower initial capital costs and lower annual operating
costs, it is no more effective in attaining water
quality goals, and may even be less effective in the longrange.
The relationship between waste water systems and land
development was examined, including residential, industrial
and open space land uses. It was found that installation
of the large-scale regional system followed rather
than preceded increases in population and density; also,
the amount of open space available for water-based recreaticn
did not increase as a result of the regional system.
Finally, induntrinl wutor u~or3, for tho moot pnrt, did
not m:1ko use of tho \-(.lute w~1tor :;y:;toM, refuting tho
notion thut tho system necoonnrily contributes to industrial
development opportunities.
While existing lnrgo-scole systems mny not necessarily
promote development, in at least ono case it was found
that exclusion of a proposed regional system in favor of
small-scale local systems wus effected os a means of restricting
future lond development. Tho proposal for o
regional system was defeated by local comities in an
effort to maintain low-density residential pbtterns and
exclude industry; these same communities were found to have
exclusionary zoning practices. In general, it was found
that waste water planning decisions tend to strengthen the
unequal distribution of wealth, reinforce divisions in
class structure, and maintain exclusionary residential
patterns. Tho costs of pollution control vary considerohly
from one area to the next, and are allocated without re
Description
Keywords
Department of Sociology Regional waste water Land use